The Best Harry Potter Scenes That Got Left Out Of The Movies
The Harry Potter films may be magical for many viewers, but for die-hard fans of the books, they sometimes only feel like part of the story.
J. K. Rowling managed to pack seven novels to the brim with rich details, emotional arcs, and clever foreshadowing, so it makes sense why translating the Wizarding World into eight movies would be tough. And unfortunately, that challenge often meant leaving behind certain moments from the books that added depth, clarity, and heart to the tale.
Sure, plenty of cuts were crucial for saving time, but others felt plain unnecessary, leaving fans downright disappointed. So, here are some of the most important scenes from the Harry Potter book that sadly never made it to the big screen.
The Missing Diadem of Ravenclaw
One of the most pivotal moments in the hunt for Horcruxes got axed in the films thanks to a small change in “The Half-Blood Prince.”
When Harry hides his potion textbook in the Room of Requirement, he comes across a bust wearing a dusty wig and an old tiara. He doesn’t give it much thought, but those who read the books were rewarded later when the tiara was revealed to be the long-lost Diadem of Ravenclaw, one of Voldemort’s final Horcruxes.
Sadly, the sixth Harry Potter movie completely skips this moment. So, when Harry suddenly “senses” the Diadem’s location in “The Deathly Hallows: Part 2,” it feels forced instead of foreshadowed.
The Society for the Promotion of Elfish Welfare (S.P.E.W.)
Hermione’s passion project, S.P.E.W., may have brought some comic relief to “The Goblet of Fire,” but it also revealed a deeper theme within the series: the fight against systemic injustice. Her advocacy for house-elves’ rights shaped her character, led to important interactions with Dobby, and introduced Winky, another house-elf who was left out of the films entirely.
Sign up for Chip Chick’s newsletter and get stories like this delivered to your inbox.
Aside from that, the exclusion of S.P.E.W. created a domino effect, particularly when it came to Ron and Hermione’s first kiss. In the books, their kiss comes after Ron shows concern for the elves’ safety, so without S.P.E.W. in the films, the kiss lacks some emotional foundation.
Tracking Down The Locket
Fans who only watched the movies might think the locket Horcrux came out of nowhere, but fans of the books know better. Hidden during a brief scene in “The Order of the Phoenix,” Harry and the gang stumble upon a locket while cleaning the Black family home.
At the time, it seemed like junk, and they just tossed it aside. Yet, if you fast forward two books later, that same locket becomes a key piece of Voldemort’s soul. Unfortunately, the movie skipped this clever callback, which is somewhat understandable, given how the final book hadn’t been written yet.
The Triwizard Tournament Prize Money
Leaving out the prize money from the Triwizard Tournament might not seem like a major loss, but people who love the Harry Potter books know it creates a baffling plot hole that becomes more glaring as time goes on.
In “The Goblet of Fire,” Harry wins 1,000 Galleons for surviving the deadly tournament, but he’s too grief-stricken by Cedric Diggory’s death to keep it. Instead, he gives all the money to Fred and George Weasley to fund their dream of opening a joke shop.
Nonetheless, no mention of the prize money is made in the films at all. So, when Fred and George suddenly open Weasleys’ Wizard Wheezes in “The Half-Blood Prince,” it seems like they pulled thousands of Galleons out of thin air.
Marietta Edgecombe
Another surprising discrepancy between the Harry Potter books and films involves the total removal of Marietta Edgecombe.
In J. K. Rowling’s “The Order of the Phoenix,” Marietta is Cho Chang’s friend and the one who betrays Dumbledore’s Army to Professor Umbridge. However, the movies cut Marietta entirely and have Cho be the one who betrays the group while under the influence of truth serum. This seemingly small switch altered Harry’s romantic storyline, since Cho was his love interest in the earlier books.
The Magical Mirror
The two-way mirror that Sirius gives Harry in “The Order of the Phoenix” is a gift that might seem minor, but it has huge implications. In the book, he stores it away and doesn’t realize it will later allow him to attempt communication with Sirius and eventually play a role in saving his life.
Nonetheless, the mirror is completely cut from the fifth movie. Then, when it suddenly reappears in “The Deathly Hallows: Part 1,” its origins aren’t properly explained.
The Quidditch Season in “Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix”
Another subplot that the fifth film skipped was the whole Quidditch season, which unfortunately meant one of Ron Weasley’s best character growth arcs was excluded.
In the book, Ron joins the Gryffindor Quidditch team as a Keeper and struggles with nerves and self-doubt. That’s until he helps lead the team to victory in a stressful match that earns Gryffindor the Quidditch Cup.
This was a defining moment for Ron, so cutting this storyline from the movie weakened his character development. Not to mention, it removed a rare moment of joy and victory from an otherwise heavy chapter in the Wizarding World.
The Death Of Peter Pettigrew
Finally, Peter Pettigrew’s death in “The Deathly Hallows” book is pure poetic justice. After betraying Harry’s parents and serving Voldemort for years, he is eventually tasked with killing Harry. But when Harry reminds him of the life debt he owes, Peter hesitates, and in that instant, the magical hand Voldemort gave him turns against him and strangles him.
The film, on the other hand, glosses over this. In “The Deathly Hallows: Part 1,” Peter is just knocked unconscious by Dobby, and by the next movie, he’s gone without much explanation.
More About:Entertainment